allic states in very thin wires due to a Cooper
pair breaking mechanism. The dissipative critical theory contains current reducing
uctuations in the guise of both quantum and thermally activated phase slips. A
full cross-over phase diagram is computed via an expansion in the inverse number of
complex components of the superconducting order parameter (one in the physical
case). The uctuation corrections to the electrical ( ) and thermal ( ) conductivities
are determined, and we nd that
has a non-monotonic temperature dependence
in the metallic phase which may be consistent with recent experimental results
on ultra-narrow wires. In the quantum critical regime, the ratio of the thermal
to electrical conductivity displays a linear temperature dependence and thus the
Wiedemann-Franz law is obeyed, with a new universal experimentally veriable
Lorenz number.
1
Introduction
At the nanoscale, the basic mechanical, electrical and optical properties of
materials that are well understood at macroscopic length scales can change
in interesting and sometimes unexpected ways as quantization and uctua-
tion e ects manifest themselves. An intriguing question thus arises regarding
the implications of reducing the scale or e ective dimensionality of materi-
als, that even in the bulk, are known to already display interesting quantum
mechanical behavior. Superconductors are natural physical systems to con-
sider in this context. Conventional or low temperature superconductors are
well understood in the bulk, unlike their high temperature cousins whose full
Email address: adrian@delmaestro.org
(Adrian Del Maestro).
Preprint submitted to Elsevier
17 July 2008 description still remains elusive after more than twenty years of intensive re-
search. A major obstacle to the study of high temperature superconducting
materials is that they are plagued by their proximity to competing states with
both order and disorder at the atomic scale. Through a better understanding
of the ways in which normal superconductivity is suppressed or destroyed in
di erent conning geometries and e ective dimensions, perhaps progress can
be made towards a mastery of this fascinating emergent phenomena at all
length and temperature scales.
Recent technological advances now allow experimentalists to fabricate and
control systems with ever smaller dimensionality. In two dimensions, thin lms
of lead with less than ten atomic layers can be grown with such precision that
mesas and valleys are intentionally engineered to trap vortices, hardening the
superconductor in a magnetic eld (1). In one dimension, a technique known
as suspended molecular templating (2) can produce long metallic wires with
diameters less than 10 nm. Finally, the fabrication and ultimate measurement
of spin excitations in manganese chains using a scanning tunneling micro-
scope in inelastic tunneling mode is an elegant example of the observation
and control of a system consisting of only a few atoms (3).
In this paper, we will focus on the transition between a superconductor and
a metal in ultra-narrow wires. It is well known that the Mermin-Wagner-
Hohenberg theorem (4; 5) precludes the possibility of long range supercon-
ducting order at any non-zero temperature in one dimension. However, any
real wire is three dimensional, and can be approximated as a cylinder with a
nite radius R. In the Landauer picture (6) conduction is proportional to the
number of channels in the wire, N , equal to the number of states that can be
occupied for a given energy in all dimensions transverse to transport. Thus, if
we imagine free electron states propagating down the wire, N
A/
2
F
where
A is the cross-sectional area and
F
is the Fermi wavelength. Any real wire will
have R
F
implying that N
1 and we can imagine that it will undergo
a phase transition to a superconducting state below some critical tempera-
ture. As the diameter of the wire decreases, or at suitably low temperatures,
it will eventually enter a regime where the superconducting coherence length,
equal to the average separation between Cooper pairs, is larger than the
radius. This condition denes the quasi-one dimensional limit, as paired elec-
trons necessarily experience the niteness of the transverse dimension while
unpaired electrons do not.
1.1
LAMH theory
The study of superconducting uctuations in narrow wires has a long history
beginning in 1968, when Webb and Warburton performed a remarkable trans-
2 port experiment on thin whisker-crystals of Sn (7) with diameters between 40
and 400 �m. They noticed that for the thinnest wires, resistive uctuations
leading to a nite voltage persisted below the bulk critical temperature (T
c
)
for tin and deed any mean eld characterization using the maximum super-
current (8). The understanding of this behavior, which is specic to quasi-one
dimensional superconductors followed rapidly thereafter and is composed of
three parts. The rst was Littles qualitative introduction of thermally acti-
vated phase slips (9); an unwinding of the phase of the superconducting order
parameter by �2 in a region of the wire where the magnitude of the su-
perconducting order parameter has been spontaneously suppressed to zero.
These non-trivial thermal uctuations are equivalent to a vortex tunneling
across the wire. In an applied bias current, negative jumps in the phase can
exactly balance the linear in time phase increase needed by the Josephson re-
lation for the system to exhibit a nite voltage below T
c
(10). Next came the
Ginzburg-Landau (GL) theory of Langer and Ambegaokar (11) for the free
energy barrier height of a phase slip event which qualitatively reproduced the
most important features of Webb and Warburtons experiments. The story
concluded with the time-dependent GL theory of McCumber and Halperin
(12) who correctly computed the rate at which these resistive uctuations
occur, and led to full quantitative agreement. The contributions of Langer,
Ambegaokar, McCumber and Halperin are now referred to as the LAMH the-
ory of thermally activated phase slips.
Transport near the nite temperature phase boundary between the supercon-
ducting and normal state is controlled by these phase slips, which from the
LAMH theory have a free energy barrier height
F (T ) and occur at a rate
(T ) at temperature T . When used in conjunction with the Josephson rela-
tion, LAMH showed that their contribution to the resistance of the wire is
given by
R
LAMH
= R
q
(T )
k
B
T e
F (T )/k
B
T
(1.1)
where R
q
= h/(2e)
2
is the quantum of resistance. This result can be applied
to a nanowire of length L and normal resistance R
N
= (4L/N )R
q
where N
is the number of transverse channels and is the mean free path to obtain the
LAMH contribution to the conductivity (13)
LAMH
= 3.4 e
2
h N
T (0)
T
c
N
3/2
1
T
T
c
9/4
exp 0.21 T
c
N
T (0) 1
T
T
c
3/2
(1.2)
or
LAMH
= e
2
h N
LAMH
T
T
c
, N(0)
(1.3)
where
LAMH
is a universal dimensionless function, T
c
is the superconducting
transition temperature and (0) is the zero temperature GL coherence length.
3 A multitude of experiments on superconducting nanowires (2; 14; 13; 15; 16;
17; 18; 19; 20) have conrmed the accuracy of the LAMH theory by tting
Eq. (1.2) to experimental transport measurements with T
c
and (0) as free
parameters with great success. This description includes the e ects of only
thermally activated phase slips, and neglects the possibility of quantum phase
slips at low temperatures (21; 22) where, if present, one would expect quantum
tunneling to produce deviations from the LAMH theory. There are some exper-
imental indications that quantum phase slips (QPT) may indeed be present at
the lowest temperatures (23; 24; 25) and we attempt to address some of these
issues in Section 3.4 by presenting a version of the LAMH theory with param-
eters renormalized by quantum uctuations. For a recent and comprehensive
review describing the inuence of both thermally activated and quantum phase
slips on superconductivity in one dimension see Ref. (26).
1.2
Ultra-narrow wires
As the diameter of a wire is reduced, there are two important changes that
need to be considered. The rst is the well known volume to surface area
ratio, and thus surface e ects will begin to a ect bulk behavior. The second is
more subtle and is related to the increased e ects of coupling to an external
environment. In the presence of such dissipation, a small system can undergo
a quantum localization transition, as is observed in small Josephson junctions
(27).
In the early 1990s, step edge electron beam lithography techniques were used
to create narrow indium strips with diameters between 40 and 100 nm. When
transport measurements were performed, there appeared to be signicant devi-
ations from the LAMH resistance at low temperatures resulting in a persisting
resistance manifest as a foot raised upwards from the expected exponentially
decreasing resistance (23; 24). It was proposed that this was due to the onset
of quantum phase slips at low temperatures occurring via the macroscopic
tunneling mechanism of Caldeira and Leggett (28). These ideas were vigor-
ously pursued (29; 30; 31; 32) leading to a host of theories which did not
necessarily agree on the observability of quantum phase slips in experiments.
One of the most interesting results was an upper bound on the wire diameter
of approximately 10 nm above which quantum phase slips would be strongly
suppressed (30) as their rate
QP S
exp( N ) can be exponentially small,
where N is the number of transverse channels in the wire discussed above.
This upper bound of ten nanometer